Skip to main content

How to Compare Security Providers on More Than the Hourly Rate

hero banner for desktop hero banner for mobile

Comparing Security Providers on More Than the Hourly Rate

How to compare security providers on more than the hourly rate

Many security tenders are decided on the hourly rate, because it is the easiest number to score. But it tells you little about the next three years: whether the same officers turn up, how quickly problems reach you, how issues are resolved, and whether a provider's claims hold up when checked.

These six questions will tell you more. Use them in your returnable schedules, on the site visit and in reference checks.

Why the rate is the wrong place to start

A low rate can hide costs that never appear on an invoice. When officers leave, new faces arrive who are still learning your site, coverage gaps appear, and your facilities team spends more time managing the provider.

Your own risk matters too. Under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015, you share duties with your security provider for the people on your site. For public sector buyers, the Government Procurement Rules already ask for the best public value over the whole life of a contract, not the lowest price.

1. Who will be on our site in 12 months?

An officer who knows your site notices the insecure door that is usually locked, recognises your regular contractors and staff and knows who to call. Ask each provider for its annual staff turnover, how long officers stay on comparable sites, and how it keeps the same officers on a site. Ask for figures, not adjectives.

2. Which certifications do you hold, and what do they cover?

"Committed to quality" is a claim; an independent certification is evidence. The three that matter most are ISO 9001 (quality), ISO 45001 (health and safety) and ISO 14001 (environment). Ask for the certificates, with the issuing body, scope and expiry date, and check that the scope covers the services you are buying.

FIRST Security is certified to all three, is an audited, accredited member of the New Zealand Security Association and holds Toitū Carbon Reduce certification.

3. Who answers the phone at 3 am?

The real test is what happens overnight and on public holidays. Ask whether there is a 24/7 operations centre staffed in New Zealand, what happens when you need additional staff deployed, a lone officer misses a check-in, and who can make decisions overnight. Better still, ask each provider to walk you through its last after-hours incident on a site like yours.

Our National Operations Centre is staffed in New Zealand around the clock. It takes client calls at any hour, coordinates resources and runs regular welfare checks on officers working alone.

4. How will we hear about incidents?

Ask for a redacted sample incident report and a monthly service report. Ask how quickly you are told about an incident, by whom, and how lessons feed back into your site instructions. A confident provider will show you its reporting, bad news included.

5. How do you keep your own people safe?

Security is physical work, often done alone and at night. A provider that keeps its officers safe keeps them longer. Ask for its serious harm record, its ACC levy status (calculated by ACC, not the provider) and what it invests in protective equipment and training.

FIRST Security has operated for more than 25 years without a workplace fatality. Over the past five years we have invested $4.2 million in driver safety, real-time monitoring, body-worn cameras and stab-resistant body armour built to the same standard as police and Corrections.

6. What happens when demand changes overnight?

Storms, outages and emergencies don't wait for a contract variation. Ask for the provider's business continuity plan, how quickly it can add officers, and a recent example. Our standing Crisis Management Team has supported clients through COVID-19, the fuel crisis and multiple natural disasters.

Putting it into your tender

  1. Bring operations onto the panel. They live with the result for years.
  2. Score continuity and incident response alongside price, and publish the weightings.
  3. Ask for evidence, not adjectives: certificates, sample reports and figures.
  4. Make reference checks specific: ask about turnover and after-hours response.

 

The same people on your site next year

The best security contract is one you rarely have to think about. The same officers turn up, your operation keeps running and your organisation stays out of the news. We're happy to answer every one of these questions in writing, before your tender goes out.

 

Talk to our team about your next security tender

https://www.firstsecurity.co.nz/newcontact